In this article, we examine four of last week’s strongest Post-Earnings Momentum (PEM) trading setups: CRWV, AVEX, CTVA, and NMAX. Despite mixed earnings fundamentals, imperfect technical setups, and a lack of clean breakouts, all four produced positive hypothetical trading outcomes, with maximum favorable excursions (MFE) ranging from +16.01% to +25.95% and next-day EOD returns ranging from +2.99% to +23.49%. Together, these long and short setups delivered an average hypothetical EOD gain of +15.39%, highlighting the opportunities and challenges of trading post-earnings momentum.

What happens when a stock surges or plunges immediately after reporting earnings?
Does that initial momentum continue? Or does the stock reverse course and leave traders holding the bag?
That’s exactly what we’ve been studying here at Paper Trading Journal since early 2026.
Our Post-Earnings Momentum (PEM) trading strategy focuses on identifying stocks that make significant price movements during the first hour following an earnings announcement.
Historical Setup Explorer
Search a stock ticker to browse every chart and image from its PTJ case study without leaving this page.
By tracking hundreds of historical earnings reactions, we’re trying to understand which conditions produce the strongest continuation moves, which technical signals matter most, and how we might approach these opportunities more systematically.
And last week’s earnings reactions provided some particularly interesting examples.
Below, we’ll examine four post-earnings trading setups involving CoreWeave (CRWV), Avex (AVEX), Corteva (CTVA), and Newsmax (NMAX).
These examples include both long and short opportunities, imperfect technical structures, mixed earnings fundamentals, and some surprisingly large continuation moves.
Let’s get into it!
CRWV Case Study: A Weak First-Hour Move That Delivered a 23% Gain
Our first setup is particularly interesting because, technically speaking, it didn’t even produce a large hourly momentum move, which we typically look for when scanning for high-probability PEM setups.
Following its earnings announcement, CoreWeave (CRWV) gained just +0.95% during the first hourly earnings candle, falling well short of our typical 5% momentum threshold.

Even more interesting was the candle’s structure.
CRWV produced a substantial −8.85% topside wick retracement. Generally speaking, large upper wicks can indicate substantial selling pressure, indecision, or disagreement among market participants about a stock’s appropriate valuation.
And in CRWV’s case, there was a potentially good reason for that uncertainty.
The company’s earnings fundamentals painted a somewhat mixed picture:
On one hand, CRWV failed to meet bottom-line earnings expectations. But on the other, the company delivered stronger-than-expected revenue and raised its forward outlook.
But here’s where things got interesting!
Despite the weak initial momentum, substantial upper wick, and lack of clean hourly, four-hour, or daily breakouts, CRWV subsequently produced one of the strongest continuation moves of the week.

A hypothetical long entry at the close of the first hourly earnings candle, held until the following trading session’s close, would have delivered approximately +23.49% before trading costs.
That’s a remarkable continuation move for a stock that initially appeared to have very little momentum.
The takeaway? A weak initial hourly close and substantial wick retracement don’t necessarily prevent a stock from subsequently producing a powerful continuation move. But that doesn’t automatically make every weak setup worth trading, either.
Learn the Fundamentals of Technical Analysis
John J. Murphy’s Technical Analysis of the Financial Markets covers charts, trends, indicators, candlesticks, intermarket relationships, and other core technical analysis concepts.
Price: $34.27–$35.50
View on Amazon →AVEX Case Study: A 16% Opportunity That Nearly Disappeared by the Close
Next up is AVEX, which provides an excellent example of both the opportunity and volatility associated with post-earnings momentum trading.
AVEX produced a substantial initial momentum move, gaining +10.23% during the first hour following its earnings announcement.

However, the technical setup wasn’t exactly perfect. The first hourly earnings candle produced a long upper wick, representing a −7.25% retracement from its high, while the stock also failed to produce clean breakouts on the hourly, four-hour, or daily charts.
Meanwhile, similar to CRWV, the company’s earnings fundamentals were somewhat mixed.
Although the earnings miss was substantial, traders and investors also had encouraging revenue results and improved forward guidance to consider.
And based on the subsequent price action, buyers clearly weren’t finished with AVEX!
After the first hourly earnings candle closed, the stock continued climbing, eventually producing a maximum favorable excursion of +16.01% relative to the hypothetical entry price.

That’s a substantial opportunity in a relatively short period… But here’s the catch…
Despite moving as much as +16% higher, AVEX eventually reversed, and by the close of the following trading session, AVEX’s price was just +2.99% above our hypothetical entry at the close of its first hourly earnings candle.

This is where profit-taking strategies become particularly interesting.
After all, had a trader been using a PT order sitting anywhere between 1-16%, they would have have hit it.
But without a PT order, a trader waiting until the end of the session would have watched most of that +16% unrealized gain evaporate into practically nothing.
The takeaway? AVEX demonstrates why MFE and realized EOD returns are two very different measurements. A setup can produce significant favorable movement without retaining those gains into the following close.
Benjamin Graham & Jason Zweig
$13.94 Listed priceCTVA Case Study: A Bearish Earnings Setup That Delivered a 19% Gain
Of the four setups we’re covering, Corteva (CTVA) might be my personal favorite.
Why?
Because, at the time, I wasn’t particularly confident it would work! Looking back, however, CTVA had several characteristics of an exceptionally strong bearish post-earnings momentum setup.
Following its earnings announcement, CTVA declined −5.91% during the first hourly earnings candle, satisfying our minimum momentum requirement for a potential short position.

Fundamentally, the company’s earnings report was mixed, but with a distinctly bearish element in its forward outlook.
Although revenue exceeded expectations, the significant EPS miss and downward guidance revision provided potential justification for the negative market reaction.
Technically, the PEM setup was also intriguing.
CTVA didn’t produce a clean breakout on the hourly, four-hour, or daily timeframes. However, the first hourly earnings candle closed remarkably close to an important long-term support level near the stock’s all-time low.

That made the setup especially interesting.
When a stock approaches a major support level following disappointing earnings, a subsequent breakdown can sometimes trigger additional selling pressure as traders react to the loss of that support.
And that’s essentially what happened with CTVA.
Following the hourly earnings candle, the stock continued declining aggressively, producing an exceptionally strong continuation move.
In fact, CTVA produced a maximum favorable excursion of +19.77% without moving adversely against a hypothetical short entry at the close of the hourly earnings candle.

That’s a HUGE intraday move! But it doesn’t mean the stock fell in a perfectly straight line.
In fact, during the following trading session, CTVA also produced an interesting technical retracement toward the 6-9-12 exponential moving average (EMA) cloud.
For traders looking for alternative entry levels, that retracement could have acted as a strong key level to either start a position or to add to an existing short position.

Following that retracement, CTVA resumed its downward movement and ultimately closed the next trading session approximately 19.26% below the hypothetical short-entry price.
The takeaway? CTVA illustrates how a stock doesn’t necessarily need a confirmed multi-timeframe breakout at the moment of entry to produce a powerful continuation move. Proximity to major support, bearish earnings guidance, and strong directional momentum can all contribute to a compelling setup.
Option Volatility and Pricing
A comprehensive guide to options pricing, volatility, trading strategies, and risk management. An excellent resource for traders looking to understand market volatility beyond simply predicting stock direction.
Check Price on Amazon →Affiliate disclosure: We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
NMAX Case Study: A 13.64% Earnings Surge That Kept Climbing
Finally, let’s look at Newsmax (NMAX), which was actually another setup that I initially wasn’t particularly optimistic about. But once again, the market did NOT care what I thought might or might not happen.
Following its earnings announcement, NMAX surged +13.64% during the first hourly earnings candle, representing one of the larger initial moves among our four examples.

This setup is actually interesting because it provided both technical and fundamental agreement. In its report, NMAX announced rather encouraging earnings results:
Unlike some of the other examples, NMAX also demonstrated relatively strong alignment between its initial bullish price momentum and reported earnings performance.
But the technical structure still wasn’t perfect.
But the strong 1-hour move and the bullish fundamentals provided more than enough reason to take this setup seriously.
After the first hourly earnings candle closed, the stock continued moving higher, reaching a maximum favorable excursion of +20.47%.
Furthermore, a trader entering long at the first hourly earnings candle’s close and exiting at the following EOD would have captured approximately +15.83% before costs.

That’s yet another an impressive return, especially considering that NMAX was already up more than 13% before our hypothetical entry.
Lastly, this setup also experienced relatively limited adverse movement, with an MAE of just −1.50%.
In other words, NMAX took off after earnings and barely looked back!
The takeaway? Strong earnings momentum and encouraging fundamental results can sometimes support continued buying even without a clean technical breakout. And a large initial earnings move doesn’t necessarily mean that a stock has exhausted its potential.
Learn the Fundamentals of Technical Analysis
John J. Murphy’s Technical Analysis of the Financial Markets covers charts, trends, indicators, candlesticks, intermarket relationships, and other core technical analysis concepts.
Price: $34.27–$35.50
View on Amazon →Conclusion: Four Imperfect Setups, Four Remarkable Outcomes
Here’s what makes these four post-earnings momentum setups so interesting. Not a single one was perfect.
CRWV lacked initial momentum, AVEX struggled to hold its gains, and neither CTVA nor NMAX produced clean multi-timeframe breakouts.
Yet all four produced meaningful gains, with next-day EOD returns ranging from +2.99% to +23.49%, and an average return of +15.39% per setup, before trading costs.
Pretty impressive considering the relatively short holding periods!
Of course, these are four of the week’s best-performing setups, not a representation of every stock we watched or traded. Plenty of other earnings reactions resulted in reversals, failed breakouts, and losses.
The big takeaway from these 4 mini case studies is that even imperfect setups can and do sometimes produce extraordinary gains.
Ultimately, trading isn’t about being right every time. It’s about about understanding opportunity and risk, and having a strategy you can execute consistently, even when the outcome is uncertain.
If you want to go deeper:
- Explore the Trading Statistics Hub to understand how different sectors behave across market cycles
- Study real setups inside the Trade Reviews section
- Learn the framework behind high-probability setups in the Post-Earnings Momentum Strategy
This is how you turn raw market data into repeatable trading edge.


Leave a Reply